Dexter Holland is one of the worst vocalists ever?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KTILLA23

That top ten list sucks! A least half of those people don't deserve to be on there! Same goes for the top 150 songs.

---

Your best offspring album list annoys the shit outta me.....No self respecting Offspring fan would have Smash 6th

Really? Disagree. Smash is in the top two for casual fans who don't really know the Offspring. Smash is #4 or #5 for me... too many overplayed songs that I was tired of before I was even a fan, plus it includes one of the top 3 worst Offspring songs ever, So Alone. Personal taste, man. Nothing to do with being a self-respecting fan.

Edit: I like Ixnay, Ignition, Self Titled, and RFRG more than Smash. The only one in his list I disagree with is CO1. Maybe their worst album there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ilovellamas

Really? Disagree. Smash is in the top two for casual fans who don't really know the Offspring. Smash is #4 or #5 for me... too many overplayed songs that I was tired of before I was even a fan, plus it includes one of the top 3 worst Offspring songs ever, So Alone. Personal taste, man. Nothing to do with being a self-respecting fan.

Edit: I like Ixnay, Ignition, Self Titled, and RFRG more than Smash. The only one in his list I disagree with is CO1. Maybe their worst album there.

---

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks this. Smash is a good album, but i don't think it's there best one. I think most people put it in there top one or two because it's the album most people heard first or the only one people heard. And i think most people would say that i put RFRG or CO1 to high on my list, but i personally love those album. And it's not like people have to agree with what i say, it's just my opinion. But in the end i love all there albums, even Splinter.

i still think smash is their best album

1- Ixnay on the Hombre
2- Smash
3- Ignition
4- Americana
5- Rise and Fall Rage and Grace
6- Co1/Self-titled
7- Splinter

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RonWelty

1- Ixnay on the Hombre
2- Smash
3- Ignition
4- Americana
5- Rise and Fall Rage and Grace
6- Co1/Self-titled
7- Splinter

---

Totally saw this coming. ...and with that, this thread becomes yet another "rank the Offspring's albums" thread...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ilovellamas

Really? Disagree. Smash is in the top two for casual fans who don't really know the Offspring. Smash is #4 or #5 for me... too many overplayed songs that I was tired of before I was even a fan, plus it includes one of the top 3 worst Offspring songs ever, So Alone. Personal taste, man. Nothing to do with being a self-respecting fan.

Edit: I like Ixnay, Ignition, Self Titled, and RFRG more than Smash. The only one in his list I disagree with is CO1. Maybe their worst album there.

---

You don't like So Alone? I love that song.

My favorite Offspring album rotates between Smash, Ignition, and Ixnay. Those three, self-titled, and Americana are always in my top 5. On my iPod, almost all the tracks on Smash have over 100 plays and I don't get tired of it. I can listen to Smash and Ignition every other day and love them both.

I still really like CO1, RAFRAG, and Splinter though.

What if so?
All great geniuses have something wrong with their voice...
... just take Stephen Hawking

EDIT: + :)

I really hate Dexter's vocals in "Self Esteem", "Gotta Get Away" and "Take It Like A Man" (album versions, of course), but most of others are great and hard to repeat in the same key.

This guy obviously don't know what his doing, he basically gave out poor criticism to Dexters voice. Don't judge A book by it's cover. Get to know that person well enough at first, then give out some more valid/constructive opinion. Plus, he just did it for the Pretty Fly song and whatevers!