I am completely unattracted to everyone in your list! I think maybe you like guys a little more "normal" than me -- I prefer my men a little goofy or weird-looking, to be honest :P Two things though:
1) The guy who plays Kili is Aidan TURNER, and he is actually pretty alright-looking but again, too "pretty" for me:
http://i.imgur.com/zvf3z.jpg
Aidan Quinn is an old man.
2) If you like Robert Sheehan (who is again, much MUCH too pretty for me :P) as a scumbag, you should watch season 1 of Misfits. In my humble opinion, his scumminess made the show nearly unwatchable for me. Later seasons feature Joe Gilgun, who is hot as hell but photographs pretty poorly most of the time.
http://i.imgur.com/8wx8i.png