I think that it is fucked up that adults sometimes abuse kids, just because they can. Though, people can be overtly sensitive and claim everything as child abuse, which I think is just stupid. It's unfortunate that the best answer I can come up with for now is "oh well, shit happens".
Oh, wait, I mean tl;dr.
My parents got divorced when I was 3 and I have no brothers or sisters. Since then I have lived one week with each of them, then switching. My dad has never laid hand on me and the one time my mother spanked me (you know the padding that just makes you feel so bad but doesn't really hurt?), he told her that if she ever did it again she wouldn't ever see me again.
I can't stand the thought of people beating their kids and worse. It sickens me that some people feel the need to hit a kid in order to make their point or get their meaning across. I mean, wtf?! How low can you go?
I don't lack any discipline and as a kid I was never unruly or a spoiled brat. If I didn't get the things I wanted I didn't go into a frenzy, screaming and crying like you see abused kids do. I never talked back at my parents or called them names. I was just disciplined through dialogue.
Have you ever seen abused kids through a fit Phil? What the hell are you talking about?
I personally don't have a problem with slapping or spanking, it's not something I would chose to do, and it seems a little white-trashish. But I wouldn't put it on a par with actually beating the child.
And Phillip, you know you're a special case. Kids are brats all the time, ESPECIALLY single children from relatively wealthy parents (which you had at one point.) And on top of that you were never a particularly rebellious person.
I got the shit kicked out of me as a kid, but I thought of it as normal. You do something disrespectful, you get smacked, plain and simple. I don't endorse that kind of behavior anymore, but there was a time when I didn't even consider it abusive. Now I do. What heats me up is when people consider being "yelled at" a form of abuse.
Oh, and tl ; dr. Seriously, I didn't read it, I just offered some comments.
Now I'm just wondering why you put slapping and spanking in a group with punching and kicking. You don't think there is a line there?
I don't endorse either, and I think there are more effective ways to punish kids. But saying that slapping is a form of child abuse, is victimizing people who aren't actually victims.